docs(prompts): Order A2 master prompt draft (Round-2 cross-review machinery for Codex) #19

Merged

pdurlej merged 1 commit from claude/orders/order-a2-prompt-draft into main

2026-05-02 02:46:03 +02:00

claude commented

2026-05-02 02:41:56 +02:00

Collaborator

Summary

Drafted by GLM-5.1 sisyphus (oh-my-opencode framework, ULW-LOOP mode) per .sisyphus/plans/order-a2-prompt.md, following prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md gold standard. 310 lines covering Round-2 cross-review machinery for the 3+3 ensemble pipeline.

Why DRAFT

Pre-Oracle-review draft. Operator pastes prompt to Oracle UI for sanity check before delegation to Codex. Same pattern as Order C prompt PR #11 (Oracle-validated before merge).

Scope (per charter §3 review-by-impact)

Small impact: docs only, single new file (prompts/order-a2-round2-cross-review.md), no behavior change → ensemble review optional. Companion evidence file in .sisyphus/evidence/order-a2-prompt-summary.md.

When Codex implements per this prompt: ~350 LOC code + ~300 LOC tests = medium impact → 3+3 ensemble required at implementation PR.

Linkage

Closes (when implementation lands) open loop reviewer-fix-patch-schema step A2 (deadline 2026-05-22)
Builds on top of A1 (fix_patch.ops[] schema, PR #18)
Defers A3 (bug-class taxonomy, PR forthcoming)
Codex implementation must use linked-worktree pattern per charter §4 v2 (PR #15)

Token-arbitrage

GLM-5.1 wrote 310 lines on flat-fee z.ai subscription. Claude orchestrator reviewed + committed (~5k tokens). Estimated savings: 15-20k orchestrator tokens.

Co-authors

GLM-5.1 (z.ai sisyphus draft via OpenCode CLI — opencode run -m zai-coding-plan/glm-5.1)
Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context, orchestrator review + commit)

## Summary Drafted by **GLM-5.1 sisyphus** (oh-my-opencode framework, ULW-LOOP mode) per `.sisyphus/plans/order-a2-prompt.md`, following `prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md` gold standard. 310 lines covering Round-2 cross-review machinery for the 3+3 ensemble pipeline. ## Why DRAFT **Pre-Oracle-review draft.** Operator pastes prompt to Oracle UI for sanity check before delegation to Codex. Same pattern as Order C prompt PR #11 (Oracle-validated before merge). ## Scope (per charter §3 review-by-impact) **Small impact**: docs only, single new file (`prompts/order-a2-round2-cross-review.md`), no behavior change → ensemble review optional. Companion evidence file in `.sisyphus/evidence/order-a2-prompt-summary.md`. When Codex implements per this prompt: ~350 LOC code + ~300 LOC tests = **medium impact** → 3+3 ensemble required at implementation PR. ## Linkage - Closes (when implementation lands) open loop `reviewer-fix-patch-schema` step A2 (deadline 2026-05-22) - Builds on top of A1 (`fix_patch.ops[]` schema, PR #18) - Defers A3 (bug-class taxonomy, PR forthcoming) - Codex implementation must use linked-worktree pattern per charter §4 v2 (PR #15) ## Token-arbitrage GLM-5.1 wrote 310 lines on flat-fee z.ai subscription. Claude orchestrator reviewed + committed (~5k tokens). Estimated savings: 15-20k orchestrator tokens. ## Co-authors - GLM-5.1 (z.ai sisyphus draft via OpenCode CLI — `opencode run -m zai-coding-plan/glm-5.1`) - Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context, orchestrator review + commit)

claude added the

ready-for-operator

label

2026-05-02 02:41:56 +02:00

pdurlej was assigned by claude

2026-05-02 02:41:56 +02:00

claude added 1 commit

2026-05-02 02:41:56 +02:00

docs(prompts): Order A2 master prompt draft (Round-2 cross-review machinery for Codex) c4485c7a33

Drafted by GLM-5.1 sisyphus per .sisyphus/plans/order-a2-prompt.md, following
prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md gold standard. 310 lines covering:
- Round-2 cross-review schema (accept/amend/reject/needs_operator verdicts)
- tools/round2.py module spec (~120 LOC)
- Integration in run_review.py main() after Round-1 ELEVATED decisions
- _ROUND_2_INSTRUCTION system prompt extension in _base.py
- 10+ tests including edge cases
- Bootstrap rule for linked worktree (per charter §4 v2 / Order C-followup)

Pre-Oracle-review draft. Operator pastes to Oracle UI before delegation to Codex.
Same pattern as Order C prompt PR #11 (Oracle-validated before merge).

Per charter §3 review-by-impact: small impact (docs only, single new file,
no behavior change) → ensemble review optional.

Closes (when implementation lands) open loop reviewer-fix-patch-schema step A2
(deadline 2026-05-22).

Co-authored-by: GLM-5.1 (z.ai sisyphus draft via OpenCode CLI)
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context, orchestrator review + commit)

claude referenced this pull request

2026-05-02 02:43:03 +02:00

docs(prompts): Order A3 master prompt draft (bug-class taxonomy + canary recall for Codex) #20

pdurlej merged commit a2694a2920 into main

2026-05-02 02:46:03 +02:00

pdurlej referenced this pull request from a commit

2026-05-02 02:46:03 +02:00

Merge pull request 'docs(prompts): Order A2 master prompt draft (Round-2 cross-review machinery for Codex)' (#19) from claude/orders/order-a2-prompt-draft into main