docs(secrets): integrate W4 closeout forks #443

Merged

pdurlej merged 1 commit from codex/w4/integrated-closeout into main

2026-05-24 20:24:53 +02:00

codex commented

2026-05-24 20:19:05 +02:00

Collaborator

Canary status: missing — integrated docs/evidence closeout PR; rely on required Forgejo checks before merge

Canary Context Pack

Product story

W4 should close without making the operator merge four status-conflicting fork PRs. This PR integrates the completed A/B/C/D fork outputs into one coherent closeout packet: identity reality, BWS recovery recon, Honcho Redis argv evidence, and W4d/W4e handoff.

What changed

Integrated Fork B (#439) identity/MCP reality check.
Integrated Fork A (#440) BWS recovery/archive recon.
Integrated Fork C (#441) Honcho Redis argv leak evidence.
Integrated Fork D (#442) W4 closeout/handoff prep.
Updated STATUS_NOW and W4 cycle output to make this integrated PR the merge target.

Why it changed

The four fork PRs all touch state/cycle/W4-secrets-access-hardening-output.md; merging them individually creates avoidable status-file conflicts. A single integrated PR preserves their evidence and gives the operator one clean merge path.

Files touched

docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/02-plan.md
docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/03-tasks.md
docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/04-current-reality.md
docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/README.md
state/L3/OPEN_LOOPS.md
state/STATUS_NOW.md
state/cycle/W4-secrets-access-hardening-output.md
state/reports/w4-closeout-prep-2026-05-24.md
state/reports/w4c-bws-recovery-archive-2026-05-24.md
state/reports/w4c-honcho-redis-argv-leak-2026-05-24.md

Relevant context

#438 ADR-0024 Infisical primary secrets pipeline
#439/#440/#441/#442 fork outputs
#56 Forgejo MCP identity split
#237 BWS/Infisical secrets injection gap
#124 Honcho Redis argv leak
#274 Token Auth rotation tracker

Runtime evidence

This integrator PR performs no runtime mutation.

Included evidence from fork outputs:

W4b: direct-curl + actor PAT from macOS Keychain is the current safe Forgejo write standard; MCP router deferred to Milestone 06 unless pulled forward.
W4c BWS recon: target historical BWS files were not found in current repo or checked RS2000 roots; archive action is metadata-only.
W4c #124: read-only metadata check found current Honcho Redis Config.Cmd does not contain the raw Redis password value; Redis still requires auth; Honcho Redis/API/Deriver were healthy at check time.
W4d/W4e: YubiKey/operator-consent and Vault sunset are follow-up milestones, not W4 closeout blockers.

Known constraints

No secret values are stored in this PR. The Honcho Redis report includes only booleans/status/length metadata, not the Redis password.

Explicit out-of-scope

No runtime apply, restart, secret migration, Vault write, or service mutation.
No merge of the superseded fork PRs #439/#440/#441/#442.
No Token Auth rotation; #274 remains open.
No full MCP router implementation.

Requested decision

Merge this integrated closeout PR instead of merging #439/#440/#441/#442 separately.

Merge blockers

Any secret disclosure, contradiction with fork evidence, or failing required checks.

Spec sources read

state/cycle/W4-secrets-access-hardening-output.md — W4 state and closure criteria
state/STATUS_NOW.md — operator-facing current state
docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/ — W4b identity/MCP plan and fork output
state/reports/w4c-bws-recovery-archive-2026-05-24.md — Fork A evidence
state/reports/w4c-honcho-redis-argv-leak-2026-05-24.md — Fork C evidence
state/reports/w4-closeout-prep-2026-05-24.md — Fork D closeout prep

Supersedes #439
Supersedes #440
Supersedes #441
Supersedes #442
Refs #56
Refs #237
Closes #124

Canary status: missing — integrated docs/evidence closeout PR; rely on required Forgejo checks before merge ## Canary Context Pack ### Product story W4 should close without making the operator merge four status-conflicting fork PRs. This PR integrates the completed A/B/C/D fork outputs into one coherent closeout packet: identity reality, BWS recovery recon, Honcho Redis argv evidence, and W4d/W4e handoff. ### What changed - Integrated Fork B (#439) identity/MCP reality check. - Integrated Fork A (#440) BWS recovery/archive recon. - Integrated Fork C (#441) Honcho Redis argv leak evidence. - Integrated Fork D (#442) W4 closeout/handoff prep. - Updated `STATUS_NOW` and W4 cycle output to make this integrated PR the merge target. ### Why it changed The four fork PRs all touch `state/cycle/W4-secrets-access-hardening-output.md`; merging them individually creates avoidable status-file conflicts. A single integrated PR preserves their evidence and gives the operator one clean merge path. ### Files touched - `docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/02-plan.md` - `docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/03-tasks.md` - `docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/04-current-reality.md` - `docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/README.md` - `state/L3/OPEN_LOOPS.md` - `state/STATUS_NOW.md` - `state/cycle/W4-secrets-access-hardening-output.md` - `state/reports/w4-closeout-prep-2026-05-24.md` - `state/reports/w4c-bws-recovery-archive-2026-05-24.md` - `state/reports/w4c-honcho-redis-argv-leak-2026-05-24.md` ### Relevant context - #438 ADR-0024 Infisical primary secrets pipeline - #439/#440/#441/#442 fork outputs - #56 Forgejo MCP identity split - #237 BWS/Infisical secrets injection gap - #124 Honcho Redis argv leak - #274 Token Auth rotation tracker ### Runtime evidence This integrator PR performs no runtime mutation. Included evidence from fork outputs: - W4b: direct-curl + actor PAT from macOS Keychain is the current safe Forgejo write standard; MCP router deferred to Milestone 06 unless pulled forward. - W4c BWS recon: target historical BWS files were not found in current repo or checked RS2000 roots; archive action is metadata-only. - W4c #124: read-only metadata check found current Honcho Redis `Config.Cmd` does not contain the raw Redis password value; Redis still requires auth; Honcho Redis/API/Deriver were healthy at check time. - W4d/W4e: YubiKey/operator-consent and Vault sunset are follow-up milestones, not W4 closeout blockers. ### Known constraints No secret values are stored in this PR. The Honcho Redis report includes only booleans/status/length metadata, not the Redis password. ### Explicit out-of-scope - No runtime apply, restart, secret migration, Vault write, or service mutation. - No merge of the superseded fork PRs #439/#440/#441/#442. - No Token Auth rotation; #274 remains open. - No full MCP router implementation. ### Requested decision Merge this integrated closeout PR instead of merging #439/#440/#441/#442 separately. ### Merge blockers Any secret disclosure, contradiction with fork evidence, or failing required checks. ## Spec sources read - `state/cycle/W4-secrets-access-hardening-output.md` — W4 state and closure criteria - `state/STATUS_NOW.md` — operator-facing current state - `docs/specs/forgejo-mcp-identity-split-v0/` — W4b identity/MCP plan and fork output - `state/reports/w4c-bws-recovery-archive-2026-05-24.md` — Fork A evidence - `state/reports/w4c-honcho-redis-argv-leak-2026-05-24.md` — Fork C evidence - `state/reports/w4-closeout-prep-2026-05-24.md` — Fork D closeout prep Supersedes #439 Supersedes #440 Supersedes #441 Supersedes #442 Refs #56 Refs #237 Closes #124

codex added 1 commit

2026-05-24 20:19:05 +02:00

docs(secrets): integrate W4 closeout forks

base-is-main / guard (pull_request) Successful in 2s

Details

canary-required / collect-diff (pull_request) Successful in 5s

Details

patchwarden-pr-sanity / collect-diff (pull_request) Successful in 5s

Details

canary-required / canary (pull_request) Has been skipped

Details

patchwarden-pr-sanity / sanity (pull_request) Successful in 22s