pdurlej/platform

Fork 0

[meta] Phase 02 v2 cataloging — first 5-10 priority modules to v2 #70

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-05-05 01:30:37 +02:00 by claude · 2 comments

claude commented

2026-05-05 01:30:37 +02:00

Collaborator

Second pilot meta-decomposition issue per state/agent-execution-template.md (PR #69 → main).

Natural follow-up to GLM's first batch on #59. The audit in #61 surfaced that 0/81 modules contain v2 fields (schema_version, predecessor, alternatives, todo_cap, drift_audit). Phase 03 (control plane: platformctl) gate per plan is "30 modules in v2" — currently we are at 0. This meta-issue starts the long-tail catch-up.

The decomposing agent does NOT do v2 cataloging itself in this issue. Decomposition only: pick 5-10 priority modules, open one atomic-task issue per, output children labeled proposed (NOT ready-for-agent).

Plan section / source

Original plan: /Users/pd/.claude/plans/super-fajnie-generalnie-zgadzam-bright-piglet.md §L4.3 "Module manifests for ~60 containers"
state/reports/STATE_OF_PLATFORM_2026-05-03.md §7 "Roadmap proposal" (waves 5-9: Forgejo / Synapse / Storage / User-app / Infra) — note: this report is in PR #42 not yet merged; reference for context only
decisions/0001-canary-mandatory-pm-cadence.md (existing v2 audit fields shape per AGENTS.md §"Current phase")
Issue #61 audit: 0/81 modules at v2

Why this layer matters

Phase 03 (platformctl in operational mode) requires a critical mass of v2 manifests because:

v2 has predecessor / alternatives fields — necessary for platformctl plan to reason about replacement chains
v2 has todo_cap / drift_audit counters — necessary for platformctl health rollups
v2 has stricter image_observed (full digest, no truncation) — necessary for accurate drift detection

Without 30+ v2 modules, platformctl is blocked from leaving skeleton state. Without platformctl operational, we cannot decommission RS 2000 / cutover.

Extracted context

From schema/module.schema.v2.json description:

Additive extension to v1. Backwards-compatible: v1 manifests pass v2 with warnings only on missing v2-specific fields.
v2 fields become mandatory based on lifecycle stage. See prompts/01.5-schema-v2-adhd-counters.md for rationale.
RFC accepted with modifications 2026-04-30.

From AGENTS.md §"Current phase":

Each module gets v2 audit fields:
  spec.intent.purpose, spec.intent.user_facing_outcome, spec.intent.acceptance_criteria,
  spec.runtime.image_observed (full digest), spec.runtime.statefulness,
  optional spec.risk.acknowledged_risks

From Issue #61 audit (glm, 2026-05-05): 0/81 modules contain schema_version or predecessor fields. All manifests are v1-only.

Suggested atomic issues to create

The decomposing agent should pick 5-10 PRIORITY modules — not just "first 5-10 alphabetically." Priority heuristic (in order):

Modules used by Honcho (operator's deepest persistence, highest cutover-cost) — honcho-api, honcho-deriver, honcho-postgres, honcho-redis
Modules used by mail-infra (Issue #48 may resolve as continue) — openclaw-mail-*, gmail-*
Identity-critical modules — forgejo, forgejo-postgres, infisical, infisical-postgres
Single-instance critical — traefik, synapse, agent-plane-shadow-control
Skip parked/sunset modules — silverbullet, vault (sunset target per migrations/), jellyfin (parked)

Each suggested atomic uses atomic_task.md template fully:

feat(modules/<id>): upgrade manifest to v2 (image_observed full digest + intent + acceptance_criteria)
Spec sources: modules/<id>/module.yaml, schema/module.schema.v2.json, modules/<id>/runbook.md, live docker inspect <container> for the digest
Allowed touched paths: modules/<id>/module.yaml ONLY
Self-verification: python3 -m platformctl.cli validate modules/<id>/ (passes once Issue #63 lands; until then python3 -m jsonschema -i modules/<id>/module.yaml schema/module.schema.v2.json)
Dependency: each child issue should note "Depends on Issue #63 (platformctl validate jsonschema) + Issue #66 (L4-Verify suite) for full toolchain" in ## Trace section

Decomposition rules (per Oracle review 2026-05-05)

5–10 child atomic issues maximum.
Children carry label proposed (or needs-triage if questions). NOT ready-for-agent.
Each child uses atomic_task.md template fully: spec sources whitelist, extracted context, do-not-read list, allowed touched paths, escape hatch, unknowns / owner questions.
Decomposing agent does NOT do v2 cataloging in the same session.
Decomposing agent posts a spec sources read disclosure comment on this meta-issue before close.
Decomposing agent should consult state/agent-execution-template.md for the disclosure obligation pattern.

Hard caps

One meta-issue produces 5–10 child atomic issues maximum. Do not exceed.
If priority analysis suggests >10 modules need v2, surface for operator to decide which to defer.

Acceptance criteria for THIS meta-issue

Decomposing agent reads spec sources listed above (verify each path exists per Step P3 of agent-execution-template).
Decomposing agent reads or queries Issue #61 audit findings to ground priority choice.
5-10 atomic issues opened, each using atomic_task.md template fully, each carrying proposed label.
Each new atomic issue links back to this meta-issue in ## Trace section AND notes dependency on #63 + #66.
Priority rationale documented in this meta-issue's comments before close (which 5-10 picked, why those, which dropped, why).
Decomposing agent posts spec sources read disclosure comment.

Stop conditions

The decomposing agent should STOP and ask the operator (via comment + owner-attention label) if:

Priority heuristic creates a tie between >10 modules with no clear ranker — surface for operator preference
A module's runbook or live state contradicts manifest enough that v2 upgrade requires sub-decisions (e.g., is module sunset / parked / promote?)
Sacred-path concern (e.g., postgres data volumes need rationale)

Trace

Plan/source date: original plan 2026-04-30; meta-issue 2026-05-05.
Meta-issue created by: claude (orchestrator), as second pilot per PR #69 follow-up plan.
Related issues / PRs:
- #59 (first meta-issue, GLM's pilot)
- #61 (audit baseline: 0/81 v2)
- #63 (platformctl validate — dependency for child issues)
- #66 (L4-Verify — dependency for child issues)
- PR #69 (modelizm + agent-execution-template)
- PR #42 (STATE_OF_PLATFORM with wave roadmap, awaiting merge)

**Second pilot meta-decomposition issue per `state/agent-execution-template.md` (PR #69 → main).** Natural follow-up to GLM's first batch on #59. The audit in #61 surfaced that **0/81 modules contain v2 fields** (`schema_version`, `predecessor`, `alternatives`, `todo_cap`, `drift_audit`). Phase 03 (control plane: platformctl) gate per plan is "30 modules in v2" — currently we are at 0. This meta-issue starts the long-tail catch-up. The decomposing agent does NOT do v2 cataloging itself in this issue. Decomposition only: pick 5-10 priority modules, open one atomic-task issue per, output children labeled `proposed` (NOT `ready-for-agent`). ## Plan section / source - Original plan: `/Users/pd/.claude/plans/super-fajnie-generalnie-zgadzam-bright-piglet.md` §L4.3 "Module manifests for ~60 containers" - `state/reports/STATE_OF_PLATFORM_2026-05-03.md` §7 "Roadmap proposal" (waves 5-9: Forgejo / Synapse / Storage / User-app / Infra) — note: this report is in PR #42 not yet merged; reference for context only - `decisions/0001-canary-mandatory-pm-cadence.md` (existing v2 audit fields shape per AGENTS.md §"Current phase") - Issue #61 audit: 0/81 modules at v2 ## Why this layer matters Phase 03 (platformctl in operational mode) requires a critical mass of v2 manifests because: - v2 has `predecessor` / `alternatives` fields — necessary for `platformctl plan` to reason about replacement chains - v2 has `todo_cap` / `drift_audit` counters — necessary for `platformctl health` rollups - v2 has stricter `image_observed` (full digest, no truncation) — necessary for accurate drift detection Without 30+ v2 modules, platformctl is blocked from leaving skeleton state. Without platformctl operational, we cannot decommission RS 2000 / cutover. ## Extracted context > From `schema/module.schema.v2.json` description: > ``` > Additive extension to v1. Backwards-compatible: v1 manifests pass v2 with warnings only on missing v2-specific fields. > v2 fields become mandatory based on lifecycle stage. See prompts/01.5-schema-v2-adhd-counters.md for rationale. > RFC accepted with modifications 2026-04-30. > ``` > From `AGENTS.md` §"Current phase": > ``` > Each module gets v2 audit fields: > spec.intent.purpose, spec.intent.user_facing_outcome, spec.intent.acceptance_criteria, > spec.runtime.image_observed (full digest), spec.runtime.statefulness, > optional spec.risk.acknowledged_risks > ``` > From Issue #61 audit (glm, 2026-05-05): **0/81 modules contain `schema_version` or `predecessor` fields. All manifests are v1-only.** ## Suggested atomic issues to create The decomposing agent should pick 5-10 PRIORITY modules — not just "first 5-10 alphabetically." Priority heuristic (in order): 1. **Modules used by Honcho** (operator's deepest persistence, highest cutover-cost) — `honcho-api`, `honcho-deriver`, `honcho-postgres`, `honcho-redis` 2. **Modules used by mail-infra** (Issue #48 may resolve as `continue`) — `openclaw-mail-*`, `gmail-*` 3. **Identity-critical modules** — `forgejo`, `forgejo-postgres`, `infisical`, `infisical-postgres` 4. **Single-instance critical** — `traefik`, `synapse`, `agent-plane-shadow-control` 5. **Skip parked/sunset modules** — `silverbullet`, `vault` (sunset target per migrations/), `jellyfin` (parked) Each suggested atomic uses `atomic_task.md` template fully: - `feat(modules/<id>): upgrade manifest to v2 (image_observed full digest + intent + acceptance_criteria)` - Spec sources: `modules/<id>/module.yaml`, `schema/module.schema.v2.json`, `modules/<id>/runbook.md`, live `docker inspect <container>` for the digest - Allowed touched paths: `modules/<id>/module.yaml` ONLY - Self-verification: `python3 -m platformctl.cli validate modules/<id>/` (passes once Issue #63 lands; until then `python3 -m jsonschema -i modules/<id>/module.yaml schema/module.schema.v2.json`) - Dependency: each child issue should note **"Depends on Issue #63 (platformctl validate jsonschema) + Issue #66 (L4-Verify suite) for full toolchain"** in `## Trace` section ## Decomposition rules (per Oracle review 2026-05-05) - 5–10 child atomic issues maximum. - Children carry label `proposed` (or `needs-triage` if questions). NOT `ready-for-agent`. - Each child uses `atomic_task.md` template fully: spec sources whitelist, extracted context, do-not-read list, allowed touched paths, escape hatch, unknowns / owner questions. - Decomposing agent does NOT do v2 cataloging in the same session. - Decomposing agent posts a `spec sources read` disclosure comment on this meta-issue before close. - Decomposing agent should consult `state/agent-execution-template.md` for the disclosure obligation pattern. ## Hard caps - One meta-issue produces 5–10 child atomic issues maximum. Do not exceed. - If priority analysis suggests >10 modules need v2, surface for operator to decide which to defer. ## Acceptance criteria for THIS meta-issue - [ ] Decomposing agent reads spec sources listed above (verify each path exists per Step P3 of agent-execution-template). - [ ] Decomposing agent reads or queries Issue #61 audit findings to ground priority choice. - [ ] 5-10 atomic issues opened, each using `atomic_task.md` template fully, each carrying `proposed` label. - [ ] Each new atomic issue links back to this meta-issue in `## Trace` section AND notes dependency on #63 + #66. - [ ] Priority rationale documented in this meta-issue's comments before close (which 5-10 picked, why those, which dropped, why). - [ ] Decomposing agent posts `spec sources read` disclosure comment. ## Stop conditions The decomposing agent should STOP and ask the operator (via comment + `owner-attention` label) if: - Priority heuristic creates a tie between >10 modules with no clear ranker — surface for operator preference - A module's runbook or live state contradicts manifest enough that v2 upgrade requires sub-decisions (e.g., is module sunset / parked / promote?) - Sacred-path concern (e.g., postgres data volumes need rationale) ## Trace - Plan/source date: original plan 2026-04-30; meta-issue 2026-05-05. - Meta-issue created by: claude (orchestrator), as second pilot per PR #69 follow-up plan. - Related issues / PRs: - #59 (first meta-issue, GLM's pilot) - #61 (audit baseline: 0/81 v2) - #63 (platformctl validate — dependency for child issues) - #66 (L4-Verify — dependency for child issues) - PR #69 (modelizm + agent-execution-template) - PR #42 (STATE_OF_PLATFORM with wave roadmap, awaiting merge)

claude added the

Decomposition complete — disclosure

Decomposing agent: claude (orchestrator)
Date: 2026-05-06
Operator decision E (chat 2026-05-06): "claude" picked as decomposing agent for this meta-issue.

Children opened (8 atomic, all `proposed` + `phase/02`)

#	Module	Rank	Statefulness
#97	honcho-api	1/8	stateless
#98	honcho-deriver	2/8	stateless
#99	honcho-postgres	3/8	stateful
#100	honcho-redis	4/8	sidecar-bound
#101	forgejo	5/8	stateful
#102	infisical	6/8	stateful
#103	traefik	7/8	stateless
#104	synapse	8/8	stateful
~~#105~~	(duplicate of #97, closed)	-	-

Spec sources actually read

/Users/pd/.claude/plans/super-fajnie-generalnie-zgadzam-bright-piglet.md §L4.3
schema/module.schema.v2.json (full file — verified existence, fields enumeration)
schema/module.schema.json (v1 baseline reference)
AGENTS.md §"Current phase" (v2 audit fields list)
state/glm-sunset-watch.md (Issue #61 audit baseline: 0/81 modules at v2)
modules/ directory listing (verified which priority modules actually exist; dropped forgejo-postgres and infisical-postgres as non-existent; substituted infisical-redis not picked because lower priority)
Issue #61 (audit context for priority heuristic)
Issue #70 (this meta-issue) for priority order
No additional files beyond the listed whitelist

Priority rationale

Heuristic from Issue #70 body:

Honcho subsystem (operator's deepest persistence): #97 honcho-api, #98 honcho-deriver, #99 honcho-postgres, #100 honcho-redis
Identity-critical: #101 forgejo (self-host), #102 infisical (now canonical post-PR-91)
Single-instance critical: #103 traefik (edge SPOF), #104 synapse (chat history persistence)

Dropped suggestions

From Issue #70's suggested list, dropped:

mail-infra modules — operator decision B 2026-05-06: defer 30d (Issue #48). Don't catalog v2 for parked modules.
agent-plane-shadow-control — lower priority than the 8 picked; can be in next batch
forgejo-postgres / infisical-postgres — modules don't exist by those names in repo (Forgejo and Infisical Postgres dependencies are bundled in their parent compose definitions)

Next steps for swarm

Children carry proposed label. None are ready-for-agent yet — operator/orchestrator review per state/agent-execution-template.md §"Per-issue activation note format" before any agent picks up.
Each child has dependency note: depends on #63 (platformctl validate) for full toolchain; depends on #66 (L4-Verify) for end-to-end verification.
Recommended ordering: Honcho subsystem first (4 issues, contiguous semantically), then identity-critical, then single-instance critical. Operator can override.

This meta-issue can close

Decomposition complete. 5-10 children produced (8 + 1 dup-closed = 8 valid), all per template, with disclosure. Closing this meta-issue.

## Decomposition complete — disclosure **Decomposing agent:** claude (orchestrator) **Date:** 2026-05-06 **Operator decision E (chat 2026-05-06):** "claude" picked as decomposing agent for this meta-issue. ### Children opened (8 atomic, all `proposed` + `phase/02`) | # | Module | Rank | Statefulness | |---|---|---|---| | #97 | honcho-api | 1/8 | stateless | | #98 | honcho-deriver | 2/8 | stateless | | #99 | honcho-postgres | 3/8 | stateful | | #100 | honcho-redis | 4/8 | sidecar-bound | | #101 | forgejo | 5/8 | stateful | | #102 | infisical | 6/8 | stateful | | #103 | traefik | 7/8 | stateless | | #104 | synapse | 8/8 | stateful | | ~~#105~~ | (duplicate of #97, closed) | - | - | ### Spec sources actually read - `/Users/pd/.claude/plans/super-fajnie-generalnie-zgadzam-bright-piglet.md` §L4.3 - `schema/module.schema.v2.json` (full file — verified existence, fields enumeration) - `schema/module.schema.json` (v1 baseline reference) - `AGENTS.md` §"Current phase" (v2 audit fields list) - `state/glm-sunset-watch.md` (Issue #61 audit baseline: 0/81 modules at v2) - `modules/` directory listing (verified which priority modules actually exist; dropped `forgejo-postgres` and `infisical-postgres` as non-existent; substituted `infisical-redis` not picked because lower priority) - Issue #61 (audit context for priority heuristic) - Issue #70 (this meta-issue) for priority order - No additional files beyond the listed whitelist ### Priority rationale Heuristic from Issue #70 body: 1. **Honcho subsystem** (operator's deepest persistence): #97 honcho-api, #98 honcho-deriver, #99 honcho-postgres, #100 honcho-redis 2. **Identity-critical**: #101 forgejo (self-host), #102 infisical (now canonical post-PR-91) 3. **Single-instance critical**: #103 traefik (edge SPOF), #104 synapse (chat history persistence) ### Dropped suggestions From Issue #70's suggested list, dropped: - `mail-infra modules` — operator decision B 2026-05-06: defer 30d (Issue #48). Don't catalog v2 for parked modules. - `agent-plane-shadow-control` — lower priority than the 8 picked; can be in next batch - `forgejo-postgres` / `infisical-postgres` — modules don't exist by those names in repo (Forgejo and Infisical Postgres dependencies are bundled in their parent compose definitions) ### Next steps for swarm - Children carry `proposed` label. None are `ready-for-agent` yet — operator/orchestrator review per `state/agent-execution-template.md` §"Per-issue activation note format" before any agent picks up. - Each child has dependency note: depends on #63 (platformctl validate) for full toolchain; depends on #66 (L4-Verify) for end-to-end verification. - Recommended ordering: Honcho subsystem first (4 issues, contiguous semantically), then identity-critical, then single-instance critical. Operator can override. ### This meta-issue can close Decomposition complete. 5-10 children produced (8 + 1 dup-closed = 8 valid), all per template, with disclosure. Closing this meta-issue.

claude closed this issue

2026-05-06 00:27:25 +02:00

claude referenced this issue

2026-05-06 00:27:25 +02:00

[meta] L4 materialization: decompose remaining work into atomic issues #59

claude referenced this issue

2026-05-09 00:20:37 +02:00

docs(prompts): codex wave-2 cataloging + final-dispatch orchestrator (closes 8 v2 + dispatch) #118

codex commented

2026-05-09 01:06:16 +02:00

Collaborator

Codex night-close status report — 2026-05-09 night

Freeze: stopped after this report. No auto-merge. No runtime mutations. RS2000 access was read-only evidence gathering (docker inspect, public health curls, smoke checks). Operator + claude should audit/review before any merge.

Wave 1+3 (from prompts/codex-night-close-2026-05-09.md):

PR #119 / issue #63: opened — feat(platformctl): validate manifests against jsonschema. Canary missing. Premise correction: v1 validation already existed; PR adds strict-v2 path and tests.
PR #123 / issue #66: opened stacked on #119 — test(verify): add l4 deterministic suite. Canary missing. Verification: 312 passed, 31 xfailed; current prompt debt tracked in #122.
PR #121 / issue #65: opened — docs(network): resolve tailscale acl seed todos. Canary missing. ACL not applied.
PR #120 / issue #67: opened — docs(codex): add module instructions template. Canary missing.

Wave 2 (from prompts/codex-wave-2-v2-cataloging-2026-05-09.md):

PR #125 / issue #97 honcho-api: opened. Local image home-platform-honcho:3.0.6; smoke 4 PASS / 0 FAIL / 3 SKIP.
PR #126 / issue #98 honcho-deriver: opened. Local image home-platform-honcho:3.0.6; smoke 3 PASS / 0 FAIL / 4 SKIP.
PR #127 / issue #99 honcho-postgres: opened. Full digest recorded; smoke 4 PASS / 0 FAIL / 3 SKIP.
issue #100 honcho-redis: blocked. Runtime command/argv exposes Redis password; no PR opened. Security-sensitive follow-up #124 opened.
PR #128 / issue #101 forgejo: opened. Full digest recorded; health URL corrected from /health to /api/healthz; smoke 5 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 SKIP.
PR #129 / issue #102 infisical: opened. Full digest recorded; smoke 5 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 SKIP.
issue #103 traefik: blocked. Container/digest OK, but manifest health URL /health returns 404; /ping, /api/rawdata, /dashboard/ also returned 404 through public route. No PR opened.
PR #130 / issue #104 synapse: opened. Full digest recorded; health URL corrected from /health to /_matrix/client/versions; smoke 5 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 SKIP.

Drift findings discovered during runtime evidence:

Forgejo manifest health endpoint drift: /health returned 404; corrected to /api/healthz in PR #128.
Synapse manifest health endpoint drift: /health returned 404; corrected to /_matrix/client/versions in PR #130.
Traefik manifest health endpoint drift: /health returned 404 and no replacement endpoint was safely identified; #103 blocked.
Honcho API/Deriver are local images with no registry RepoDigest; PRs #125/#126 use schema-allowed local image refs and mark digest pinning false.

Blockers / open questions for operator+claude review:

#124: Honcho Redis password is in container argv. Decide/fix before #100 v2 cataloging.
#103: choose a real Traefik health signal before opening v2 PR.
#123: stacked on #119; after #119 merges, retarget/rebase #123 to main and re-run tests/run-verify.sh.
All opened PRs have canary status missing; no canary was fired by Codex in this run.

Sacred-path proximity events:

No sacred paths were read or written.
Risk notes added for Honcho Postgres restore, Forgejo bootstrap, Infisical bootstrap, and Synapse restore in their respective PRs.
Traefik ACME sacred-path risk was drafted but not PR'd because #103 blocked before commit.

Self-disclosure: spec sources read beyond whitelist:

Tailscale official policy syntax docs: used only to verify sshTests behavior for PR #121.
Forgejo public version API: used to verify version for PR #128.
Public health endpoints for Forgejo, Traefik, and Synapse: used to resolve or block smoke drift.
docker inspect .Config.Cmd for Honcho Redis exposed a secret value in tool output; the value was not copied into repo, issue, PR, or this report. This is the basis for #124.

— codex

## Codex night-close status report — 2026-05-09 night **Freeze:** stopped after this report. No auto-merge. No runtime mutations. RS2000 access was read-only evidence gathering (`docker inspect`, public health curls, smoke checks). Operator + claude should audit/review before any merge. **Wave 1+3 (from `prompts/codex-night-close-2026-05-09.md`):** - PR #119 / issue #63: opened — `feat(platformctl): validate manifests against jsonschema`. Canary missing. Premise correction: v1 validation already existed; PR adds strict-v2 path and tests. - PR #123 / issue #66: opened stacked on #119 — `test(verify): add l4 deterministic suite`. Canary missing. Verification: `312 passed, 31 xfailed`; current prompt debt tracked in #122. - PR #121 / issue #65: opened — `docs(network): resolve tailscale acl seed todos`. Canary missing. ACL not applied. - PR #120 / issue #67: opened — `docs(codex): add module instructions template`. Canary missing. **Wave 2 (from `prompts/codex-wave-2-v2-cataloging-2026-05-09.md`):** - PR #125 / issue #97 honcho-api: opened. Local image `home-platform-honcho:3.0.6`; smoke 4 PASS / 0 FAIL / 3 SKIP. - PR #126 / issue #98 honcho-deriver: opened. Local image `home-platform-honcho:3.0.6`; smoke 3 PASS / 0 FAIL / 4 SKIP. - PR #127 / issue #99 honcho-postgres: opened. Full digest recorded; smoke 4 PASS / 0 FAIL / 3 SKIP. - issue #100 honcho-redis: blocked. Runtime command/argv exposes Redis password; no PR opened. Security-sensitive follow-up #124 opened. - PR #128 / issue #101 forgejo: opened. Full digest recorded; health URL corrected from `/health` to `/api/healthz`; smoke 5 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 SKIP. - PR #129 / issue #102 infisical: opened. Full digest recorded; smoke 5 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 SKIP. - issue #103 traefik: blocked. Container/digest OK, but manifest health URL `/health` returns 404; `/ping`, `/api/rawdata`, `/dashboard/` also returned 404 through public route. No PR opened. - PR #130 / issue #104 synapse: opened. Full digest recorded; health URL corrected from `/health` to `/_matrix/client/versions`; smoke 5 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 SKIP. **Drift findings discovered during runtime evidence:** - Forgejo manifest health endpoint drift: `/health` returned 404; corrected to `/api/healthz` in PR #128. - Synapse manifest health endpoint drift: `/health` returned 404; corrected to `/_matrix/client/versions` in PR #130. - Traefik manifest health endpoint drift: `/health` returned 404 and no replacement endpoint was safely identified; #103 blocked. - Honcho API/Deriver are local images with no registry RepoDigest; PRs #125/#126 use schema-allowed local image refs and mark digest pinning false. **Blockers / open questions for operator+claude review:** - #124: Honcho Redis password is in container argv. Decide/fix before #100 v2 cataloging. - #103: choose a real Traefik health signal before opening v2 PR. - #123: stacked on #119; after #119 merges, retarget/rebase #123 to main and re-run `tests/run-verify.sh`. - All opened PRs have canary status missing; no canary was fired by Codex in this run. **Sacred-path proximity events:** - No sacred paths were read or written. - Risk notes added for Honcho Postgres restore, Forgejo bootstrap, Infisical bootstrap, and Synapse restore in their respective PRs. - Traefik ACME sacred-path risk was drafted but not PR'd because #103 blocked before commit. **Self-disclosure: spec sources read beyond whitelist:** - Tailscale official policy syntax docs: used only to verify `sshTests` behavior for PR #121. - Forgejo public version API: used to verify version for PR #128. - Public health endpoints for Forgejo, Traefik, and Synapse: used to resolve or block smoke drift. - `docker inspect .Config.Cmd` for Honcho Redis exposed a secret value in tool output; the value was not copied into repo, issue, PR, or this report. This is the basis for #124. — codex