pdurlej/platform

Fork 0

chore(verify): resolve current L4 prompt budget and cross-link debt #122

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-05-09 00:53:04 +02:00 by codex · 1 comment

codex commented

2026-05-09 00:53:04 +02:00

Collaborator

Context

While implementing issue #66 (chore(verify): L4-Verify deterministic check suite), Codex found existing repo violations that should not be silently fixed inside the test-suite PR.

The new test suite should gate new drift, but these current violations need their own cleanup pass.

Scope

Resolve or intentionally waive current prompt token-budget violations.
Resolve or intentionally waive missing literal relative paths referenced from prompts/*.md.
Keep this separate from issue #66 so the verification suite stays additive.

Acceptance criteria

tests/test_l4_verify.py no longer needs xfail tracking for these current violations.
Any remaining long prompt has an explicit owner/orchestrator-approved exemption.
Any missing prompt path is either created, corrected, or explicitly classified as a non-literal/planned output reference.

Current L4 verify violations observed by Codex

Prompt token budget violations

prompts/01.5-schema-v2-adhd-counters.md: estimated 3806 tokens > 2000
prompts/01.5c-pm-decision-packet.md: estimated 2021 tokens > 2000
prompts/codex-night-close-2026-05-09.md: estimated 4267 tokens > 2000
prompts/codex-wave-2-v2-cataloging-2026-05-09.md: estimated 3036 tokens > 2000
prompts/order-a1-fix-patch-schema.md: estimated 2416 tokens > 2000
prompts/order-a2-round2-cross-review.md: estimated 2850 tokens > 2000
prompts/order-a3-bug-class-taxonomy.md: estimated 2905 tokens > 2000
prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md: estimated 2129 tokens > 2000
prompts/phase-02-wave-3.md: estimated 2503 tokens > 2000
prompts/phase-02-wave-4.md: estimated 2548 tokens > 2000
prompts/tooling-canary-workflow-rewrite.md: estimated 4754 tokens > 2000
prompts/tooling-smoke-sh-rewrite.md: estimated 3770 tokens > 2000

Missing literal prompt cross-links

prompts/01-freeze.md: 13 missing literal paths
- baseline/recovery/PROCEDURES.md
- baseline/recovery/verify-baseline.sh
- cron/jobs.json
- inventory/domains-2026-XX-XX.yaml
- inventory/mac-snapshot-2026-XX-XX.yaml
- inventory/rs2000-domains-2026-XX-XX.yaml
- inventory/rs2000-snapshot-2026-XX-XX.yaml
- inventory/vps1000-snapshot-2026-XX-XX.yaml
- state/L0/rs2000_inventory.json
- state/L0/vps1000_inventory.json
prompts/01.5-schema-v2-adhd-counters.md: 1 missing literal paths
- audit/openclaw-platform-2026-04-25/findings-register.md
prompts/01.5c-pm-decision-packet.md: 3 missing literal paths
- state/DECISION_REQUIRED.md
- state/L4/review-pipeline-pattern.json
prompts/02-catalog.md: 7 missing literal paths
- L3/OPEN_LOOPS.md
- platformctl/safety.py
- platformctl/tools/validate_module.py
- state/DECISION_REQUIRED.md
- state/L1/wip_triage.json
- tools/run_review.py
prompts/03-control.md: 4 missing literal paths
- policies/change/core-default-v1.yaml
- tests/test_smoke.py
- transport/tailscale.py
prompts/04-observability.md: 7 missing literal paths
- alerting/alertmanager-config.yaml
- compose/observability/compose.yaml
- live-platform/generator/grafana-dashboards.py
- live-platform/generator/livesite.py
prompts/05-agent-execution.md: 3 missing literal paths
- .codex/instructions.md
- automation/renovate.json
- policies/change/core-default-v1.yaml
prompts/06-prune.md: 2 missing literal paths
- automation/renovate.json
- policies/image-prune.yaml
prompts/codex-night-close-2026-05-09.md: 22 missing literal paths
- .codex/README.md
- .codex/examples/forgejo.md
- .codex/instructions.md
- .codex/render.py
- Status/platform-force-push-2026-05-08-night/pre-flight.md
- examples/forgejo.md
- practices/agent-coordination-protocol.md
- practices/credential-management.md
- prompts/codex-pr-53-rebase.md
- tests/conftest.py
- tests/run-verify.sh
- tests/test_l4_verify.py
prompts/codex-platform-final-dispatch-2026-05-09.md: 2 missing literal paths
- agent-souls/practices/agent-coordination-protocol.md
- practices/agent-coordination-protocol.md
prompts/codex-wave-2-v2-cataloging-2026-05-09.md: 2 missing literal paths
- Status/platform-force-push-2026-05-08-night/pre-flight.md
- practices/credential-management.md
prompts/order-a1-fix-patch-schema.md: 12 missing literal paths
- control-plane/platformctl/tests/test_fix_patch.py
- control-plane/platformctl/tools/fix_patch.py
- platformctl/tests/test_fix_patch.py
prompts/order-a2-round2-cross-review.md: 14 missing literal paths
- control-plane/platformctl/tests/test_round2.py
- control-plane/platformctl/tools/round2.py
- platformctl/tests/test_fix_patch.py
- platformctl/tests/test_round2.py
- state/reviews/PR-N/round2.json
prompts/order-a3-bug-class-taxonomy.md: 14 missing literal paths
- control-plane/platformctl/tests/test_taxonomy.py
- control-plane/platformctl/tools/taxonomy.py
- platformctl/tests/test_taxonomy.py
- state/reviews/_taxonomy_alert.md
prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md: 5 missing literal paths
- control-plane/platformctl/identity_doctor.py
- git/askpass-codex.sh
- platformctl/tests/test_codex_askpass.py
prompts/phase-02-wave-3.md: 2 missing literal paths
- .sisyphus/scripts/run_review.py
- compose/apps/compose.yaml
prompts/phase-02-wave-4.md: 3 missing literal paths
- .sisyphus/scripts/run_review.py
- baseline/recovery/PROCEDURES.md
- compose/apps/compose.yaml
prompts/tooling-canary-workflow-rewrite.md: 2 missing literal paths
- state/reviews/PR-44-v2/decision_packet.md
prompts/tooling-smoke-sh-rewrite.md: 15 missing literal paths
- compose/apps/compose.yaml
- state/reviews/PR-40/decision_packet.json
- state/reviews/PR-40/decision_packet.md
- tests/setup.sh
- tests/smoke-extra.sh

## Context While implementing issue #66 (`chore(verify): L4-Verify deterministic check suite`), Codex found existing repo violations that should not be silently fixed inside the test-suite PR. The new test suite should gate new drift, but these current violations need their own cleanup pass. ## Scope - Resolve or intentionally waive current prompt token-budget violations. - Resolve or intentionally waive missing literal relative paths referenced from `prompts/*.md`. - Keep this separate from issue #66 so the verification suite stays additive. ## Acceptance criteria - `tests/test_l4_verify.py` no longer needs xfail tracking for these current violations. - Any remaining long prompt has an explicit owner/orchestrator-approved exemption. - Any missing prompt path is either created, corrected, or explicitly classified as a non-literal/planned output reference. ## Current L4 verify violations observed by Codex ### Prompt token budget violations - `prompts/01.5-schema-v2-adhd-counters.md`: estimated 3806 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/01.5c-pm-decision-packet.md`: estimated 2021 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/codex-night-close-2026-05-09.md`: estimated 4267 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/codex-wave-2-v2-cataloging-2026-05-09.md`: estimated 3036 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/order-a1-fix-patch-schema.md`: estimated 2416 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/order-a2-round2-cross-review.md`: estimated 2850 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/order-a3-bug-class-taxonomy.md`: estimated 2905 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md`: estimated 2129 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/phase-02-wave-3.md`: estimated 2503 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/phase-02-wave-4.md`: estimated 2548 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/tooling-canary-workflow-rewrite.md`: estimated 4754 tokens > 2000 - `prompts/tooling-smoke-sh-rewrite.md`: estimated 3770 tokens > 2000 ### Missing literal prompt cross-links - `prompts/01-freeze.md`: 13 missing literal paths - `baseline/recovery/PROCEDURES.md` - `baseline/recovery/verify-baseline.sh` - `cron/jobs.json` - `inventory/domains-2026-XX-XX.yaml` - `inventory/mac-snapshot-2026-XX-XX.yaml` - `inventory/rs2000-domains-2026-XX-XX.yaml` - `inventory/rs2000-snapshot-2026-XX-XX.yaml` - `inventory/vps1000-snapshot-2026-XX-XX.yaml` - `state/L0/rs2000_inventory.json` - `state/L0/vps1000_inventory.json` - `prompts/01.5-schema-v2-adhd-counters.md`: 1 missing literal paths - `audit/openclaw-platform-2026-04-25/findings-register.md` - `prompts/01.5c-pm-decision-packet.md`: 3 missing literal paths - `state/DECISION_REQUIRED.md` - `state/L4/review-pipeline-pattern.json` - `prompts/02-catalog.md`: 7 missing literal paths - `L3/OPEN_LOOPS.md` - `platformctl/safety.py` - `platformctl/tools/validate_module.py` - `state/DECISION_REQUIRED.md` - `state/L1/wip_triage.json` - `tools/run_review.py` - `prompts/03-control.md`: 4 missing literal paths - `policies/change/core-default-v1.yaml` - `tests/test_smoke.py` - `transport/tailscale.py` - `prompts/04-observability.md`: 7 missing literal paths - `alerting/alertmanager-config.yaml` - `compose/observability/compose.yaml` - `live-platform/generator/grafana-dashboards.py` - `live-platform/generator/livesite.py` - `prompts/05-agent-execution.md`: 3 missing literal paths - `.codex/instructions.md` - `automation/renovate.json` - `policies/change/core-default-v1.yaml` - `prompts/06-prune.md`: 2 missing literal paths - `automation/renovate.json` - `policies/image-prune.yaml` - `prompts/codex-night-close-2026-05-09.md`: 22 missing literal paths - `.codex/README.md` - `.codex/examples/forgejo.md` - `.codex/instructions.md` - `.codex/render.py` - `Status/platform-force-push-2026-05-08-night/pre-flight.md` - `examples/forgejo.md` - `practices/agent-coordination-protocol.md` - `practices/credential-management.md` - `prompts/codex-pr-53-rebase.md` - `tests/conftest.py` - `tests/run-verify.sh` - `tests/test_l4_verify.py` - `prompts/codex-platform-final-dispatch-2026-05-09.md`: 2 missing literal paths - `agent-souls/practices/agent-coordination-protocol.md` - `practices/agent-coordination-protocol.md` - `prompts/codex-wave-2-v2-cataloging-2026-05-09.md`: 2 missing literal paths - `Status/platform-force-push-2026-05-08-night/pre-flight.md` - `practices/credential-management.md` - `prompts/order-a1-fix-patch-schema.md`: 12 missing literal paths - `control-plane/platformctl/tests/test_fix_patch.py` - `control-plane/platformctl/tools/fix_patch.py` - `platformctl/tests/test_fix_patch.py` - `prompts/order-a2-round2-cross-review.md`: 14 missing literal paths - `control-plane/platformctl/tests/test_round2.py` - `control-plane/platformctl/tools/round2.py` - `platformctl/tests/test_fix_patch.py` - `platformctl/tests/test_round2.py` - `state/reviews/PR-N/round2.json` - `prompts/order-a3-bug-class-taxonomy.md`: 14 missing literal paths - `control-plane/platformctl/tests/test_taxonomy.py` - `control-plane/platformctl/tools/taxonomy.py` - `platformctl/tests/test_taxonomy.py` - `state/reviews/_taxonomy_alert.md` - `prompts/order-c-codex-askpass.md`: 5 missing literal paths - `control-plane/platformctl/identity_doctor.py` - `git/askpass-codex.sh` - `platformctl/tests/test_codex_askpass.py` - `prompts/phase-02-wave-3.md`: 2 missing literal paths - `.sisyphus/scripts/run_review.py` - `compose/apps/compose.yaml` - `prompts/phase-02-wave-4.md`: 3 missing literal paths - `.sisyphus/scripts/run_review.py` - `baseline/recovery/PROCEDURES.md` - `compose/apps/compose.yaml` - `prompts/tooling-canary-workflow-rewrite.md`: 2 missing literal paths - `state/reviews/PR-44-v2/decision_packet.md` - `prompts/tooling-smoke-sh-rewrite.md`: 15 missing literal paths - `compose/apps/compose.yaml` - `state/reviews/PR-40/decision_packet.json` - `state/reviews/PR-40/decision_packet.md` - `tests/setup.sh` - `tests/smoke-extra.sh`

codex referenced this issue

2026-05-09 00:56:33 +02:00

test(verify): add l4 deterministic suite #123

codex referenced this issue

2026-05-09 01:06:16 +02:00

[meta] Phase 02 v2 cataloging — first 5-10 priority modules to v2 #70

claude referenced this issue

2026-05-09 23:32:20 +02:00

test(verify): add l4 deterministic suite #123

claude referenced this issue from a commit

2026-05-09 23:43:29 +02:00

docs(prompts): codex cleanup prompt — #122 (token-budget waivers) + #124 (honcho-redis secret) + #100 (cataloging)

claude referenced this issue

2026-05-09 23:44:14 +02:00

docs(prompts): codex cleanup prompt — #122 + #124 + #100 (combined) #136

pdurlej referenced this issue from a commit

2026-05-09 23:48:18 +02:00

Merge pull request 'docs(prompts): codex cleanup prompt — #122 + #124 + #100 (combined)' (#136) from claude/orders/codex-cleanup-122-124 into main

codex commented

2026-05-09 23:51:36 +02:00

Author

Collaborator

Role: executor
Intent: checkpoint
Needs owner: no

Packet M is paused by its own stop condition: PR #123 / tests/test_l4_verify.py is not present on origin/main yet, so the waiver/archive cleanup would be editing a test file that does not exist on main.

I am not starting #122 until #123 merges or the cleanup prompt is amended to base on #123 explicitly.

Next: merge/retarget #123, then re-run Packet M.

**Role:** executor **Intent:** checkpoint **Needs owner:** no Packet M is paused by its own stop condition: PR #123 / `tests/test_l4_verify.py` is not present on `origin/main` yet, so the waiver/archive cleanup would be editing a test file that does not exist on main. I am not starting #122 until #123 merges or the cleanup prompt is amended to base on #123 explicitly. **Next:** merge/retarget #123, then re-run Packet M.

claude referenced this issue

2026-05-09 23:54:00 +02:00

test(verify): cherry-pick L4-Verify suite to main (fix #123 base_ref oversight) #137

codex referenced this issue

2026-05-10 00:06:54 +02:00

chore(verify): clean up active prompt cross-link debt #138

codex referenced this issue from a pull request that will close it,

2026-05-10 00:14:39 +02:00

test(verify): add l4 prompt waivers #139

pdurlej closed this issue

2026-05-10 00:17:09 +02:00

codex referenced this issue